• We have one of the lowest consignment rates around at just 25% (the minimum consignment fee is $500).
  • We list every saddle that comes into stock on our website, Facebook page, Instagram page and Ebay.
  • We have a 3,000 sq ft saddle studio in Chapel HIll, NC where clients can try saddles in person.
  • We offer trailer-in saddle fittings at our facility with local Certified Saddle Fitters.
  • We have a Certified Saddle Fitter on staff.
  • We have all 5* reviews on Google and Facebook.
  • We run paid advertisements regularly on social media.
  • We have regularly run ad campaigns with The Chronicle of the Horse (print and online), The Plaid Horse and several “AA” horse shows.
  • In addition to traditional advertising, we also have sponsored riders throughout the US and abroad that represent our brand at shows and recommend us to clients and other riders.
  • We currently have over 8,500 Facebook followers, over 3,000 Instagram followers and post regularly on social media.
  • All of our saddles that are shipped out on trials are fully paid for prior to shipping.
  • We now offer FREE shipping on all of our outgoing saddles.
  • We are one of the only saddle sellers that offers a financing option to our clients.


We offer Consignment services for high-end brand saddles at a low rate of 25% (minimum consignment fee of $500). We provide shipping for all incoming saddles (see below). The incoming shipping fee is $75 (this includes full insurance) and will be deducted from your payout once the saddle sells, so no need to pay for shipping up front!

Simply follow these steps to consign your saddle with us:

  1. Complete the form below
  2. We will reply to your request via Email and we will let you know the recommended list price
  3. Electronically sign the Consignment Agreement (link here:
  4. Next, print 2 copies of the shipping labels provided.
  5. Wrap your saddle in bubble wrap (please no styrofoam/packing peanuts) and place your saddle in a box that is approximately 14”x14”x24” up to 18”x18”x24” *Make sure to use a Double-Wall box or reinforce a Single-Wall box with additional cardboard on all sides. Single-Wall boxes with no reinforcement will not be covered by our shipping insurance policy.*
  6. Place one shipping label inside the box and tape the other shipping label on the top of the box.
  7. Drop the saddle off at any UPS store or any UPS access point (CVS, Staples and others – find a location near you here:

Your saddle will be shipped UPS Ground with full insurance. We will send you an email to confirm its arrival with us.

Your saddle will be detailed/cleaned, photographed and advertised within 1 business day of its arrival.

We will let you know when your saddle is heading off on trial or when it has been purchased.

Finally, we will process your payout through Paypal (no fees will be taken out), by mailed check or you can use the credit towards a saddle order (or refund a previous order). We can also send it to you through a bank transfer directly to your bank account for $20 to cover the bank fees (we just need your routing number and account number).

Please note: Once the saddle has arrived with Highline Tack or Fineline Tack and is listed as a consignment, the saddle can only be transitioned to a Trade-In for an additional $150 fee. However, a saddle that arrives as a Trade-In can be transitioned to a Consignment at no additional cost.


*We are currently accepting saddles manufactured within the last 10 years (and listed over $2000).*

If your saddle doesn’t meet our guidelines, Direct Saddles may be a great option for you!

Consignment Request

Please fill out the information below and we will email you back within 24 hours.

"*" indicates required fields

Please note, this is to create your shipping label for shipping your saddle to us. There is no obligation to proceed with consignment by filling out this form.
Upload photos of your saddle here. Please include one photo of the stamp (usually located under the flap or on the underside of the saddle)
Drop files here or
Max. file size: 256 MB.
    Year, size, leather type (grain, full calf, full buffalo etc). Any additional information is helpful.
    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    *Please note that there is a $40 charge for saddles that arrive for consignment without a cover. Saddle brand covers are accepted as well as plain (no logo) fleece-lined covers. Fleece-only covers are not accepted*

    *There is a $100 fee for removing a consigned saddle from our stock to cover cleaning and advertising time and expenses. The owner is also responsible for the shipping costs (incoming and outgoing).

    *If you would like to consign a mid-range brand saddle, please visit our sister store, Fineline Tack: